Rated 4.8 on Trustpilot

Read Reviews

Illustration comparing two roofs: panels sitting flush within the roof covering and panels mounted on rails above the tiles

·

Roofing

In-Roof vs On-Roof Solar Panels: Which Is Right for You?

In-roof panels sit flush with the roof and replace some of the tiles. On-roof panels sit on rails above them. Here is how the two compare, and when in-roof makes most sense.

By

Solar Panels London

·

Last reviewed

On-roof panels are fixed to rails that sit above your existing tiles or slates. In-roof panels replace part of the roof covering and sit flush within it, inside a weatherproof tray and flashing kit. On-roof is the usual choice for an existing roof. In-roof makes most sense when the roof is being replaced or built anyway, or when a flush, low-profile look matters. We fit both, and our roofing team can combine in-roof solar with a re-roof.

Key points

  • On-roof panels sit on rails above the tiles. In-roof panels replace part of the roof covering.

  • In-roof gives a flatter, neater look, which can suit street-facing roofs.

  • In-roof is easiest on a new roof or a re-roof. On an existing roof it means removing tiles.

  • In-roof panels have less air behind them, so they can run slightly warmer.

  • The panel and in-roof kit must be a certified combination under MCS 012, including fire classification.

  • Replacing a single in-roof panel later is more involved than on an on-roof system.

How each one is built

On-roof

Hooks are fixed to the rafters, between the tiles or slates, and rails are fixed to the hooks. The panels clamp onto the rails, with an air gap between the panels and the roof. The roof covering stays in place underneath and keeps the building watertight. Our guides to solar on slate roofs and solar on flat roofs cover different roof types.

In-roof

A section of tiles or slates is left out, and a mounting tray or flashing system is fixed to the battens in its place. The panels sit in the tray, roughly level with the surrounding roof, and the flashing joins them to the tiles around the edge. The panels and flashing become part of the roof’s weatherproofing.

Illustration of a cross-section of an in-roof panel sitting in a tray within the roof, next to an on-roof panel on rails above tiles

How they compare

Appearance. In-roof panels sit almost flush, without the raised edge of an on-roof array. Many people prefer the look, especially on street-facing roofs. If you live in a conservation area, check the planning position first. Our guide to planning permission for solar panels in London explains the rules.

Output. On-roof panels have air flowing behind them. In-roof panels have less, so they can run a little warmer and produce slightly less in hot weather. Modern n-type panels lose less output to heat, which narrows the gap. Our guide to which solar panels to choose explains temperature coefficients.

Weatherproofing. On-roof keeps the full roof covering in place. In-roof relies on the tray and flashing being installed correctly, so the quality of the roofing work matters more.

Maintenance. On-roof panels can usually be lifted off individually. Replacing an in-roof panel can mean working on the flashing around it.

Roof work. In-roof replaces some tiles, so it fits naturally into a new roof or re-roof. On an existing roof, tiles have to come off and be disposed of or stored.

When in-roof makes sense

  • You’re re-roofing anyway. The panels go in as part of the new covering, while the scaffolding is up.

  • It’s a new build or extension. The roof is designed around the panels from the start.

  • Appearance matters most. A flush look on a prominent roof.

If your roof is in good condition and you aren’t replacing it, on-roof is usually the simpler choice. Our guide to whether you need a new roof before solar helps you decide whether to do both together.

Illustration of a house being re-roofed with scaffolding up and in-roof solar panels being fitted as part of the new roof

Request a solar and battery quotation

Send your details and we’ll call you back to arrange a free survey.

We install across London and up to around 50 miles out.

No obligation. We’ll call you back within one working day (Mon–Fri, 9am–5pm). We only use your details to deal with your enquiry. See our privacy policy.

Certification and fire safety

Products mounted above or integrated into pitched roofs have to be tested and certified to MCS 012, the standard for pitched-roof mounting kits. For in-roof systems, the panel and the in-roof kit form part of the roof covering, so the fire classification has to cover the exact combination being installed. MCS published new guidance for fire-testing laboratories on roof-integrated systems in November 2026, so this area is changing. We only fit in-roof combinations that are certified for use together, and we confirm the products at survey.

In-roof and SPL Roofing

Because SPL Roofing is part of the same company, we can plan a re-roof and in-roof solar as one job: one survey, one scaffold and one team responsible for the roof and the panels. Our guide to removing solar panels for roof repairs covers the situation where you already have panels and the roof needs work.

Frequently asked questions

Is in-roof solar more likely to leak?

Not when it is installed correctly with a certified kit, but more of the weatherproofing depends on the installation. That’s why we treat in-roof as roofing work as well as solar work.

Can in-roof panels be fitted to my existing roof?

Yes, but tiles or slates have to be removed where the panels go. If the roof is near the end of its life, it is usually better to re-roof and fit the panels at the same time.

Do in-roof panels produce less electricity?

They can produce slightly less in hot weather, because they run a little warmer. Over a year, the difference is usually small compared with orientation and shading.

Does in-roof solar need planning permission?

The same rules apply as for on-roof panels. Most homes don’t need permission, but conservation areas, Article 4 areas and listed buildings can. Our guide to Article 4 directions in London explains the restrictions.

Talk to us about in-roof solar

Request a solar and battery quotation and tell us if you’re planning roof work. We’ll look at both options and recommend the one that suits your roof.

Request a solar and battery quotation

Send your details and we’ll call you back to arrange a free survey.

We install across London and up to around 50 miles out.

No obligation. We’ll call you back within one working day (Mon–Fri, 9am–5pm). We only use your details to deal with your enquiry. See our privacy policy.

Latest Articles

Ready to Start Saving with Solar?

Get your free no-obligation quote today. Our experts will design the perfect system for your home.

Free Home Survey

MCS Certified

Reply in 1 Working Day

© 2026 Solar Panels London. All rights reserved.

SOLAR PANELS LONDON (SPL) LIMITED, registered in England and Wales, company number 14360308. Registered Office, 20 Rosslyn Crescent, Luton, LU3 2AU. SOLAR PANELS LONDON (SPL) LIMITED is an Introducer Appointed Representative of Shermin Finance Limited, FRN 727594, company number 01276121. Registered Office, Homeserve, Cable Drive, Walsall, WS2 7BN. Shermin Finance Limited act as a credit broker and is not a lender. Credit is subject to status and affordability.